Canadian PM Carney Rebukes Trump’s 51st State Proposal at Oval Office Meeting

Editor
By
3 Min Read
President Donald Trump meets Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney in the Oval Office of the White House, Tuesday, May 6, 2025, in Washington. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on Tuesday firmly rejected President Donald Trump’s suggestion that Canada become the 51st U.S. state.

He made his stance clear during Oval Office talks that centered on the imposed U.S. tariffs which have continued to hurt Canadian exports.

Carney arrived at the White House fresh from an election win built on promises to defend Canadian jobs. “We value our special relationship with the United States,” he said before the meeting, “but we will protect our sovereignty and seek new trade partners.”

Inside the Oval Office, Trump praised Carney’s reputation. He then told the Canadian leader, “The U.S. doesn’t need Canada nearly as much as Canada needs us.” Trump mused that the border between the two countries is “an artificial line.” He went on to say that merging Canada with the U.S. would create a “beautiful country.”

Carney did not waver. He answered, “Canada is not for sale, never has been, never will be.” His brief reply drew nods from diplomats seated nearby.

The two leaders also sparred over U.S. tariffs of up to 25% on Canadian steel, aluminum, auto parts, and energy products. Carney warned that these duties cost Canada billions in lost exports. He said they also disrupt supply chains on both sides of the border.

Trump defended his “America First” approach. “I set trade terms like a super luxury store,” he said. “I decide who comes in and at what price.” He offered no immediate plans to lift the taxes.

Carney told reporters he expected “tough but fair” talks. “We will take all the time needed for a good deal,” he said. He added that Canada is also talking with other nations to lessen its reliance on one market.

The meeting touched on security and climate change. Carney thanked the U.S. for past cooperation in Afghanistan. He said Canada will keep backing a “rules-based world order.” Trump praised Canada’s NATO support but said all allies must “pay their fair share.”

No major breakthroughs came from the meeting, however, both sides agreed to keep talking as Carney’s firm stand shows Canada will guard its independence even as it seeks better ties with its top trading partner.

Pan-Atlantic Kompass

TAGGED:
Share This Article